On April 24th, 2025, a band I put together played their first gig. This was a project that was about three years in the making. I’m going to outline how this came about, what went well, and what mistakes were made along the way.
Back in 2022, I started writing songs and playing guitar in earnest. Truth be told, I bought my first guitar in 1997 or so, learned a few things, and even wrote a song, but put it away for years at a time. Every once in a while, I would pull it out and try again, but I struggled with it. Around 2020, I got a new guitar and realized that it was much easier to play, and I soon realized that my struggles were not all me but a guitar that was poorly set up.
With that new guitar, I learned a bunch of new chords and some techniques and started writing songs. I wrote a couple of very simple songs starting in 2021, and at some point, shared them with a musician friend of mine who ran an open mic. She convinced me, in the fall of 2021, to get on stage and play some songs. Even back then, I mostly played originals. My thinking was that I didn’t want to butcher other people’s songs.
That first time onstage, I was terrified. My legs shook, and when I heard myself in the monitor, I sounded so loud that I backed away from the microphone. I had no idea that people couldn’t hear me at all when I did that. In spite of all that anxiety, I was hooked and started playing open mics wherever I could find them.
In 2022, I wrote over 20 songs and fragments of many, many more. All the songs over the next two years told the story of a semi-unrequited love that became more unrequited as time went on. I threw myself into the pain of that situation, knowing full well what I was doing.
I played as many open mics as I could find. When I was in Illinois, I traveled from Palatine to Oak Lawn and from Downers Grove to Rogers Park. When I was in Central Pennsylvania, I would drive up to 1 1/2 hours each way to go to open mics, as there was not much going on musically in State College. In many ways, there still isn’t much going on. They need more venues that have adequate space and don’t cater exclusively to undergrads, as they don’t have much interest in small original bands.
In the summer of 2024, I walked into a Gallery Cabaret on a Tuesday night. They had just changed the format of what they were doing that night, and I had no idea it was a type of open mic. The guy running it knew me and asked me if I wanted to play. Luckily, I had my guitar in the car, so I said yes.
A few minutes later, he came up to me and gave me the lineup for the band he put together for me. I was in a state of panic. I had never done that before, and I, for the most part, play originals. I got on stage with a lead guitarist, a drummer, and a bass player, gave them keys for each song, and somehow we played. It was a great feeling. From then on, when I went to open mics that had “spare parts” as they were called at one place, I would grab some people and put little makeshift bands together. My favorite place to do this was The Outta Space in Berwyn. The guys I played with there added so much to my simple little songs.
I started to learn what fit with what I do and what didn’t. I also found ways my songs could be pushed.
When I got back to State College, PA, the last remaining truly open mic had closed. There was almost no place to play on a regular basis. Eventually, one opened in a town about 30 minutes away, but it just didn’t have the same vibe. I would go, but it was not the place where you’d meet musicians.
A few months later, someone started an original, open mic at the bowling alley bar. He came in with a drum kit, and I thought it would work out. Unfortunately, he only brought the drums out once and started booking opening acts who were then supposed to support the open-mic players. Most of the time, when they were done, they just wanted to get out. I started to dread going, but I kept at it.
By February, the open mic was struggling to find opening bands, and he started taking solo players. I said I would play the 45-minute opening set, and we settled on May 8. I figured if I had that time and a secured gig, I might be able to dig up a band, and if I couldn’t, I would play solo. Eventually, I found some people, but we were all involved with other projects, so we didn’t get much of a chance to rehearse until the end of March. I figured it was fine, we’d have plenty of time. Then the date got moved up to April 24, and we were only able to meet twice as a full band to rehearse.
On April 24th, Surly Martyrs made their debut. People seem to enjoy it, but as usual, I struggled to believe them. There was no one whom I really trusted to gauge the performance.
I did learn some things about where I want to take the music next. I just hope we can keep the core together and that they will be willing to help me build toward the really vague vision I have.
I am uploading most of the songs to My YouTube Channel.